Rhode Island FC's third season came to an end rather abruptly, falling to the Charleston Battery 5-4 in a penalty shootout after surrendering a 90+4 minute equalizer in the Eastern Conference Quarterfinals on Oct. 30. Rhode Island had played some of the best soccer of their season in the opening half, and after taking the lead through Jojea Kwizera when the Rwandan collected his own blocked penalty for an early goal in the 28th minute, RIFC looked poised to advance for the third time past the Battery at Patriots Point.
That was until the second half, when Battery Head Coach Ben Pirrmann made critical adjustments, helping Charleston find its way back into the contest, leading to forward Miguel Berry equalizing at the death, forcing the game into extra time and the eventual collapse in penalties elevating the Battery past RIFC for the first time in three seasons of postseason matchups. The defeat marked Rhode Island FC's earliest playoff exit in club history after reaching back-to-back Eastern Conference Finals and a USL Cup Final, all on the road. Head coach Khano Smith acknowledged that the club's previous postseason success shouldn't be considered an expectation.
“We have no divine right to be in the Eastern Conference Final,” Smith said when asked about failing to make a deeper run. “I think we were very fortunate to make it the first two years.”
RIFC has quickly established itself as a perennial postseason team, having made the playoffs three years in a row. It remains only one of three teams that remain flawless in postseason appearances across the USL Championship, joining the ranks of Louisville City FC, which joined the league in 2015 and Detroit City who moved from the National Independent Soccer Association to the Championship in 2021.
Goalkeeper Koke Vegas offered an interesting perspective on how the club should evaluate its third season, particularly given the expectations established by its first two playoff runs.
"Of course," Vegas said when asked whether the season could be considered successful without winning a trophy. "Only three teams leave with a trophy in the USL each season. We’re not talking about just the cup. We are talking about conference finals and USL Cup (Prinx Tires) finals. So three teams out of 25 teams is not a lot. I totally get the point that people could be disappointed or frustrating because different reasons."
Vegas acknowledged that the disappointment surrounding the early playoff exit is understandable, but believes it also reflects the standards the club has established.
"It talks about how high our standards or expectations are, and we want more. Of course, we want more. We need to want more," Vegas said. "I think home was key, and we really appreciate always everything when we played at home. This year, I think there was an even a bigger connection with the atmosphere that created the defense in the stadium."
RIFC finished the regular season with a 12-6-12 record, the season performance saw the Amber and Blue climb as high as fourth place before dropping points in the final stretch of the season saw the club drop to the seventh seed in the Eastern Conference.
The contrast between Rhode Island's home and away performances was one of the defining characteristics of its 2026 campaign. At Centreville Bank Stadium, RIFC established themselves as one of the more difficult teams to play in the Championship, surrendering just two defeats in front of their home supporters while nearly doubling their goal production from the previous season. Smith credited a combination of the team's growth, the playing surface and the atmosphere created by supporters for making Pawtucket such a difficult destination for opponents.
"We talk about teams needing to suffer when they come here," Smith said. "I think it's a combination of everything: supporters making it hard, but also think it's just the growth of the group." Smith also added that he believes the opposition doesn’t make it easier just because they’re the ones visiting. "I think we always get 10% better of the opposition when they come here."
That same confidence didn't translate to the road, where Rhode Island finished without a single draw and suffered 10 defeats. For a team that had previously built much of its identity around being difficult to beat away from home, the inability to salvage points from close matches became a costly weakness.
Smith acknowledged that the club's approach in certain moments may need to change, particularly when protecting a result rather than continuing to push for a victory.
"We need to do better, but my goal is not going to be let's get a draw on the road,” Smith said. “Any draw on the road in this league is good because all the venues are tough. Maybe at some point when I look at my role in that."
Vegas, who played in all but one game across all competitions this season, also recognized the challenges on the road.
"The USL Championship is one of the most challenging leagues in the world. I don't know how many leagues in the world you have with those distance in a way games, different altitudes, different time zones with some fields that are grass, turf, university fields, baseball fields," Vegas said. "You can't compare to the MLS. MLS have charters, we are on commercial flights. So you put all those things together and it talks a lot about how difficult it is to play away."
But with three seasons completed, two major goals continue to elude Smith and Vegas: hoisting the USL Cup and playing a home playoff match at Centreville Bank Stadium. Now, with the “Rhode Warrior” mindset that carried the club through deep playoff runs gone, the question remains as to what needs to change for Smith – and RIFC by extension – to take this club to the next level.
The benefits of a longer offseason
The October exit gives Rhode Island an additional month to evaluate its roster, identify shortcomings and make personnel decisions before preparations for the 2027 campaign begin. It's an opportunity Smith hasn't had during the club's previous two offseasons, when postseason runs left little time to reflect before the next season's preparations began.
"The silver lining for me is that we actually get time to really rest and reflect on what we're doing instead of straight into preparing for next year. We never really got a real offseason," Smith said. "Year one, it was like everything was a tornado. We just made the final year one, and then we're trying to sign players, telling players they're not coming back. It's Thanksgiving. Get to December. It's Christmas. It was the same situation again last year."
That additional time could be particularly valuable as the club evaluates its tactical identity, offensive approach and personnel decisions heading into 2027.
In three seasons, Rhode Island has demonstrated an ability to compete defensively and grind out results, but there have been stretches when the attacking approach lacked consistency, creativity and a reliable source of goals, which was further compounded by the departure of JJ Williams midseason to Hearts of Midlothian and Clay Holstad on loan to FC Dallas.
Smith acknowledged that the team needs to improve its offensive production, while also emphasizing the physical demands of the USL Championship.
"We still want to score more goals. Obviously, we scored more than last year, but I’d still like to score more," Smith said. "This league is so physical, so we always need to continue to get physical. So adding more physicality to the team, but not just track athletes, not just people that are going to go out there and wrestle. People that have that good blend of being physical and playing soccer."
Despite reinforcements through MLS loans in Philadelphia Union forward Stas Korzeniowski and Orlando City Winger Yutaro Tsukada, along with Osman Foyo from AFC Wimbledon, Rhode Island's attacking production began to dry up as the playoffs approached. Only two of the club's final nine goals before Charleston came from forward players.
There was measurable progress in 2026, with RIFC increasing its total goal production by 44.6% following a club-worst season in 2025. However, the underlying problem remains: Rhode Island has now gone two consecutive seasons without a double-digit goalscorer in league play. Williams remained the club's leading scorer with 12 matches left before his midseason departure.
A returning core leaves questions about the bench
The central question heading into the offseason is whether Rhode Island has a USL Cup-caliber foundation that needs a few key additions or whether the club requires a more significant overhaul. Its commitment to roster continuity offers some clues.
14 players returned from the 2025 roster, including nine who have been with the club since its inaugural season. However, the last two campaigns have ended with the club in the same Eastern Conference position.
By comparison, the Tampa Bay Rowdies – who finished the 2026 season with the best record in the USL Championship – retained just two players from their 2025 campaign under newly appointed Head Coach Dom Casciato. Rhode Island has taken a considerably different approach, and Smith believes the continuity is important.
"If you look at the starting lineup and the majority of guys that played the majority of minutes, they will be back," Smith said.
The club has already secured new contracts for Koke Vegas, Amos Shapiro-Thompson and Hugo Bacharach, while Jojea Kwizera, Osman Foyo, Leo Afonso and Nick Scardina are also under multi-year deals. With much of the starting group expected to return, this offseason is unlikely to require a complete overhaul. Instead, Smith's attention will turn toward strengthening the rotation and finding the additional attacking pieces necessary to compete for a championship.
"Overall, we didn't get much impact from our bench this year, which we have in the past. So that needs to be addressed," Smith said while sharing his role in their use. “It's how I am preparing them to go in. Am I giving them the right information? Am I caught up in the game and what's going on? But ultimately, they need to go in and make a difference too.”
The lack of production from the bench becomes particularly important when considering how many of Rhode Island's defeats were decided by narrow margins. Late goals conceded in the final three matches also highlighted the importance of game management and having players capable of making an immediate impact.
Smith took responsibility for some of those shortcomings, acknowledging that the coaching staff needs to improve its substitutions and preparation of players entering matches.
"Every game's a coin flip where it's small details that make the difference and I think our season is a microcosm of that," Smith said. "We just need to clean up those details. Imagine if we turned in five more draws this year instead of 10 losses. It's just the fine margins of making plays and making actions when we need to, but that's all. It starts with me making better decisions."
For Smith, that means two priorities: building a more dependable depth in the roster and forging a new attack.
Finding the next forward and replacing loaned players
In the attack, things will be arguably more difficult. Only 12 teams in the Championship produced double-digit strikers this year and with Williams’ transfer came a reliance on loaned players that never found similar heights to the departed striker. Rhode Island's relationship with loans has been a rollercoaster since 2024, and while the season presented a fresh set of challenges, it also left a team with some key question marks going into the offseason.
The 2026 season saw the largest number of loaned players for RIFC in a single season, with four players on the roster. Lanus midfielder Augustin “Pity” Rodriguez – the only initial loan – was plagued with injuries in the back half of the season, having missed nine matches before returning to play just five minutes in extra time before having his penalty blocked to end RIFC’s season.
Tsukada, Korzeniowski, and New England Revolution’s Eric Klein all joined the team in the summer as additions to missing players and positions of need.
With the exception of Klein, all of those players started in a majority of their appearances for the club, leaving Smith with some immediate roster needs to address heading into the offseason.
"There's always going to be turnover. The three start with the loanees. The chance of them being back ... they have parent clubs, so their parent clubs need to make decisions," Smith said.
Smith was also complimentary of what the loan players provided during the 2026 campaign, particularly in filling the void left by JJ Williams.
"JJ was a massive piece that we needed to replace, and I think Stas did an excellent job with that," Smith said. "Yutaro was a player that we didn't have, and he had some really good moments for us."
The loaned group of four combined for just 10 goal contributions on the season, representing just 14% of total contributions available. Granted, they did not play a full season with the club or benefit from a pre-season, but at the risk of always being recalled from loan – which is something RIFC is very familiar with – it's a risk that Khano most likely will not explore.
But that work will have to start at addressing changes at center forward, where Smith didn't leave much ambiguity about where the club's recruitment priorities begin.
“JJ was a massive piece that we needed to replace, and I think Stas did an excellent job with that,” Khano said. “This league is so physical, and we always need to continue to get physical. So adding more physicality to the team, but not just track athletes, not just people that are going to go out there and wrestle. [We need] that good blend of being physical [and being able to] play soccer.”
That points toward a like-for-like replacement for Williams: a strong, physical center forward who can hold up the ball, bring the attacking pieces around him into play and still contribute to the team's overall quality in possession.
But is a single forward enough for Rhode Island? 2024 was the best goal-scoring year in club history, and it was also the year with the deepest pool of talent. Williams was a late arrival to the season that saw the early minutes of the season carried by the likes of Albert Dikwa, Noah Fuson, and Mark Doyle.
And yet in the following seasons, replacements were not found after the departure of Doyle and Dikwa ahead of each season, further reducing the ability to find goals. With Noah Fuson entering the offseason in his worst form and at risk of also departing with no confirmed contract in place, it’s more than just replacing a single striker. It’s rebuilding an entire strike force that right now only contains Osman Foyo, who most often plays as a wide player.
Can loans augment the roster rebuild? Of course, but they can’t be the stars of the show and instead be there to fight for competitive minutes. For Smith to keep the lion’s share of this team together means he has to execute perfectly on his forward acquisitions and depth pieces to be able to look comfortably at being a top four team in the East in 2027.
A schedule that works for the club, the fans and the standings
Not every offseason improvement needs to happen on the field. A large talking point this season has been Rhode Island’s 12th man and a disturbing trend of declining attendance year-over-year. Despite being fifth in overall attendance in the Championship, RIFC’s attendance fell by 3% in 2026.
Those crowds demonstrate the potential of the Pawtucket venue and the importance of creating an appealing matchday experience, and two large talking points kept the club from multiple sellouts this season: the weather and match start times.
Being the primary tenant at Centreville Bank Stadium means the choice time for dates and kickoff. For the first time ever, RIFC opted to standardize that time to 7:30 PM for all but two of their Championship season. A decision agreed upon between the front office and technical staff.
And while no one could have predicted that RIFC would face rain in every home match of the season with the exception of two games. Season Ticket Members, group-ticket fans, and casuals trying the stadium out for the first time were not always thrilled with the late start times.
The club has already committed to restructuring match times to earlier times for next season, especially in the early spring and fall months, but it’s not just the time of day the match begins that hampered the club this season.
The other scheduling priority should be the opening weeks of the season. RIFC spent a majority of the season chasing the standings, being one of a handful of teams with the most games in hand in 2026, often three games behind the rest of the conference. The reasons behind that were mostly out of Rhode Island’s control with a bye in the opening weeks of the season – something they have experienced to start all three seasons – and an unpredictable record blizzard that blanketed Centerville Bank Stadium in snow, forcing the opening match of the season to be rescheduled as a midweek contest in the final three weeks of the regular calendar.
"Every year we've had a bye in the first two to three weeks, and then Charleston and Tampa win their first two games, and they're six points ahead, and we're already playing catch-up," Smith said. He expanded that playing at home wasn’t even a priority. "I don't care. I just want to play the first month and play somewhere, and not have a bye and not be behind those teams. It'd be nice not to play catch-up because psychologically that has an impact."
And while there were multiple instances along RIFC’s season where dropped points didn’t provide the club any favors in the table standings, an early bye can disrupt preparation, interrupt momentum and leave a club watching conference rivals accumulate points while it waits for another opportunity to play. That disadvantage can be particularly frustrating when a team is also trying to establish chemistry with new signings and integrate changes to its tactical system.
The irony? Former RIFC President and now USL President of Competition and Administration controls much of the scheduling process. Whether it’s related to the exit that saw the sports executive return to a headquarters role or an issue with the larger Championship landscape that uses Rhode Island’s scheduling flexibility as a band-aid, Smith and the front office have made it clear they aren’t satisfied.
Rhode Island FC doesn't need to abandon what has made the club successful for 2027. It needs to build on that foundation and raise the standard for what comes next.
It needs to be able to meet fans where they are and strengthen the community. It needs to be the season where player acquisitions are executed flawlessly, and it needs to be the season RIFC stops being satisfied with making the playoffs and starts building a team capable of winning the ultimate prize.
If you have enjoyed our coverage, consider becoming a paid subscriber or making a one-time donation